A True Tale of Fright
As Told by Kristina, aka Cuore Della Luna

It wasn’t a dark and stormy night at all, it was actually nice and calm that night, which is typical for Colorado. Nice people, nice scenery, nice weather…well, most of the time. Occasionally, all that niceness just gets to be too comfortable, and Mother Nature will bear down on us with a nice Blizzard, just to remind us all that she’s still in charge. But that Halloween, she was very kind to us, and it was still 60 degrees out when the sun dipped below the mountains.
I was 15, young, pretty and so unaware of it, and being naturally a shy person, with normal teenage insecurities, I was thrilled to have been invited to a party, a real party, with my friends from the 10th grade class. It was Cindy’s birthday party, held on the Saturday before Halloween. It was 1987….Michael Myers had managed to scare us all with that white mask and bloody knife, then came Jason, to haunt our summer camps and of course, Freddy had come along to invade our dreams. Some of us had never seen the Damien movies, or the Exorcist, too young to be sneaking into theatres when they first came out, and parents unwilling to put those nightmarish thoughts into our tiny heads. VCRs were still an expensive toy to own, mostly for taping things off of TV, and video stores were still getting established. But still, we knew the plot lines, from someone’s older brother who had seen it, and told his sibling to torture and scare him, who in turn, told all of us. That Halloween time, yes, our heads were filled with images of teenage slasher films, even if only in our subconscious. It’s only natural, when you’re a teenager yourself, at a party with other teenagers, to have those thoughts dancing in the shadows.
I can’t remember whose idea it was to play with the Ouija board, or even who brought it. We were all sitting in the living room, with candles as our only light source. Cindy and her boyfriend, John, had managed to “sneak” away into Cindy’s bedroom to have some alone time. I had been eyeing Brian, a boy from my church, wishing I could be doing the same thing. Danielle was there, and Amber (with her appropriately long, lush, red curly locks), Jennifer, my neighbor from up the street, and some other kids were around whose names escape me now. But since Brian was there, in the living room, willing to participate in the Ouija Board experience, well, then so was I.
My parents had a Ouija board, the kind that Parker Brothers still makes, and had since I could remember. My sister and I had tried to play with it, after I discovered it one boring summer day in the closet, but nothing ever happened. I had been so frustrated with it, because I had read those directions so carefully, followed every step it said to get it to work, and still, nothing would happen. But, that was the kind of child I was, so sure that if you just followed the steps, followed directions, obeyed, then everything should work out as planned. It’s funny to think on that now, as the painful lessons of young adulthood have taught me so well that directions are merely guidelines, and obedience is not often rewarding.
All of us, me, Amber, Danielle, Brian, and a couple of others, each had two fingers lightly resting on the planchette, and were moving it around in the figure 8, as we knew to do. Jennifer, because of her faith, decided not to join us, but stayed on the sidelines to watch. I remember feeling the electric current, the thrill of having my body so close to Brian’s, as was necessary to have us all fit around the board. We giggled and laughed, wondering what we should ask the board. Finally, someone asked “Is anyone here? Would anyone like to speak to us?” We all watched as the planchette moved to “Yes”. Then we all accused the others of moving it, each in turn, denying it. I know that I didn’t move it; I just felt it trail along to the answer. So, once we all quieted down again, I asked “What is your name?” The planchette slowly moved to the letter “J”, then to “O”, then more quickly to “H” and “N” before it came to rest in the center. “John”, I murmured. Things became quieter, as people who had been talking in the corner came over to watch us. Someone else asked “How old are you?” The planchette moved to the number “6”. Then I said “Awww”. It felt somehow safe, and sad, to know that we were talking to the ghost of a 6-year-old little boy named John….if it was indeed true, and someone wasn’t moving the planchette around to scare the rest of us. I was straddling the fence in that mysterious, tumultuous place called adolescence, on the one side, wanting to believe in the magic, that of course a sweet little boy was talking to us through this board, and on the other side, encountering the skepticism that only going through adolescence can teach, that becomes so easy and natural once in adulthood, knowing that of course, someone was moving the planchette, trying to fool us all.
Suddenly, we heard a loud crash and bang from upstairs. Immediately, as a test, I turned to the board and asked “What just happened upstairs?” The planchette began to move slowly to “T”, then “H”, then “E”, then more quickly to the rest of the letters before it came to rest in the center, to form a complete sentence:
“THEYBROKETHEBED”

Amber jumped up and ran upstairs to find out what happened. We heard people talking and laughing upstairs, and then Amber came to the head of the stairs, a little bit pale, and breathed out “Oh my God you guys, they did, Cindy and John were wrestling on her bed, and they broke the headboard off the rails, and so the mattress fell off its rails. They really did break the bed.”
Immediately, we all took our hands away from the board, all of us shivering a little, laughing some at the excitement from it. I think we all had been assuming that one of us was pushing it, but how could any of us know what had happened upstairs? My heart began to race at the thought that maybe it was a real spirit talking to us. Could it be? The thought frightened and thrilled me.
Amber rushed back upstairs to tell Cindy and John what had happened on the Ouija board, and so they both came downstairs calmly, slightly puzzled and bewildered (and not tucking or straightening out their clothes, I noticed…I guess they really were play wrestling when the headboard broke). We all quickly jumped in to tell them both of what had happened with the Ouija board.
John was always the most secure of all of us, studious, more of an old soul, and in our teenage excitement, he was able to absorb what we told him, and somehow, by telling him the story, I felt better, not as frightened by it. John was smaller than all of his classmates, which made his pairing with Cindy seem perfect, since she was so petite. I had always held a secret crush on John, for his calming ways, the way he seemed to be breezing through his teenage years, despite his physical limitations in stature, his confidence. I remember at a dance at the high school, a really great song came on, and I was dancing with reckless abandon, completely feeling the music, loving that my body could move to the rhythm. I turned on a spin to seeing John talking to another person, and he was looking and pointing at me, and I saw him say “She’s a really great dancer.” I was high all night from that chance comment that I got to witness. Ever since then, he had held a special place in my heart, the place reserved for those that have shown me kindness. I was happy for him, that he found Cindy, but also a little sad, seeing how much he was falling in love with her, because I felt I had lost out on something special.
The party wound down after that, as curfews seemed to suddenly come crashing down on it. I went home, exhilarated, thrilled at the encounter with this Ouija board, and a little boy named John. Did I dare believe it?
At school on Monday, it was all we could talk about between classes. Amber and I then decided to have everyone involved meet at my house and try it again, this time with my Ouija board, just to test it out. Maybe it was just that board that it would work on, and nothing would happen on mine.
After school, Danielle, Amber, Brian, Cindy and John all came over to my house, and I got my parent’s Ouija board out of the closet. Jennifer had declined the invitation, since she felt that we were messing with something that we just shouldn’t. Cindy was a little afraid of it, so she just wanted to watch, and John stayed by her side. Cindy agreed to take notes for us.
We each again put our two index fingertips on the planchette. This time, we asked if John was there, and the planchette moved quickly to “Yes”. We each began to ask questions of him, and as the letters became sentences, and sentences became thoughts, the story of John began to become clearer.

John had been killed on May 14, 1965, when he was hit by a ’57 Chevy in front of his house, on Murray Blvd., across from our high school. He was very excited, he spelled out, because he was about to be reincarnated into a new little boy, who was to born the next afternoon, at Penrose Hospital. The parent’s names were Clearborn, he had spelled out for us, Mary and Martin Clearborn. I could almost feel his excitement and happiness at this chance to be a person again, and I felt happy for him, too.
However, as I caught myself in this feeling, the skepticism in me began to rise, and so I asked that we try a test. We each, in turn, would take our fingers and place them on the planchette, and ask John a question, something simple, like “Are you here, John?” or “Are you with us, John?” The planchette refused to move, for any of us, except for Danielle. I did notice that it moved much more slowly to the “Yes” answer than it had when we all had our fingers on the planchette, but move it did. John asked Danielle point blank if she had been moving it on purpose, trying to scare us, and she shook her head and said plainly, “No”, that she wasn’t moving it, she wasn’t making this up.
Her calmness in the face of being accused of moving the planchette made me question whether she really had been moving it, that her calmness meant that she was lying to us. If it had been me, I would have answered with a resounding “NO! Of course I’m not doing it!” The fear of someone thinking I was lying would have come out loud and clear in my voice. It didn’t in hers…she seemed to expect that her “No” was enough, and that she had nothing else to prove then. To this day, I still wonder if she really was trying to fool us, although I can’t reconcile why she would do it. She was well-liked by everyone in this little group, and then also, how could she know that the sound of the crash was the breaking of the bed? I then wonder if maybe, just maybe, Danielle was a little bit psychic, a sensitive, and that she was receptive to the communications from the dead, and that maybe she’d been aware of it for some time by then, and so had no problem with being accused of faking it for the rest of us…she just knew better. If she was, I pray for her now, that she has been able to handle this gift, or curse, and that by being “outed” that day, she has been able to cope with it well in her life now.

We resumed asking the board questions, with Amber, Brian, Danielle and I touching the planchette again, and suddenly, the planchette began moving in a figure 8, something we hadn’t intended. We all looked at Danielle, and John asked her again if she was doing it. She had a look of fear on her face this time, the kind that only a teenager can give, the kind that shows up when someone is deathly afraid that they will no longer be accepted by her peers. She stammered out “No, NO! I am NOT doing this!” That caused my heart rate to rise a bit then, because she sounded sincere this time. Suddenly, the planchette started to spell out letters again for us, quickly, so quickly that Cindy could barely keep up with writing them as we spoke them out to her. Put together, it spelled
“HEWILLNEVERBEFREEOFMEHEISMINEHEISMINEHEISMINEHEISM…”
All of us, our eyes became very wide, and our pupils became very wide. My heart was in my throat. As if on cue, we all took our fingers off of the planchette at the same time. What we saw then scared me so much that I had tears in my eyes.
The planchette halted right in the center, stopped utterly in its tracks.
If someone had truly been pushing on it, the planchette should of kept going a little on that waxed, unused board, pushed on by the velocity it had when it was spelling out that horrid message. It didn’t, it stopped dead in its tracks, right in the middle, with no other movement. We all looked at each other, fear and wonder in each of our eyes. Danielle looked at all of us angrily, breathing fast, eyes wide with fear, and asked “Now, NOW do you believe me?”
Cindy read back to us what had been spelled out…not that she really needed to, since we all seemed to grasp the evil intent of that message as it was being spelled out. We each in turn caught our breath, calmed a bit, and we decided to try the board again.
We asked John if he was still here. The planchette slowly, more slowly than before, moved to “Yes”. We then asked if he was alright, and it moved to “No”. We asked if someone else was with him, and it moved to “Yes”. We asked who it was. It spelled out for us:
“MYFATHER”

A new take on his story began to emerge, and as it was told to us, letter by letter, word by word. The movements went more quickly, each of us saying the letters as they were spelled out for us. John spelled out that it was his father that had been driving that ’57 Chevy, and that he had murdered John by running over him. He then said that his father now had him in a cage, and that he was afraid, because he didn’t know if he was going to be able to be born again, or to meet his new parents, Mary and Martin.
Then, again, the planchette moved around in the figure 8, quickly, and each of our eyes grew wide, and my heart began to pound again. A lump formed in my throat as the planchette began to move again, so fast, so fast the planchette practically leaped from letter to letter, and again, a new set of letters formed for us:
“HEISMINEHEISMINEYOUAREALLGOINGTODIEYOUAREALLGOINGTODIE
IWILLKILLYOUALLIWILLKILLYOUALLHEISMINEHEISMI…”
That was it. We all took our fingers off the planchette, thoroughly frightened, and called it a day. Suddenly homework and parents seemed like gifts to us, the perfect excuse to just get away from what we had just seen. The normal world, the real world, what a blessing it seemed to me right then. They all left, and there I was, putting the Ouija board away before my parents got home, heart still pounding, tears forming in my eyes. I was afraid, afraid for myself, afraid for my friends, and afraid for little John.

I know now that I was wrapped up, obsessed with what this Ouija board was telling us, in a way that only teenagers seem to be able to do. It was all that I thought about all that next day at school. I was frightened, yes, but exhilarated as well. It was binding us all closer together; we were becoming a group, something I had craved for so long, a tribe of my own. And Brian was a part of it, and John, and that was worth more to me than anything frightening that this wooden board would tell us.
Amber, Danielle and I decided to go to the new Penrose Birth Center the next day after school, before we were all to meet at my house to try the Ouija board again. It was right up the street from our neighborhood, so we figured it would be a quick trip before we all went to my house. We wanted to see if maybe, just maybe, there was child named Clearborn that had been born there. Amber and I were determined that if this was true in any way, we wanted to see him, this little baby. This was in the day where anyone could go look at the newborns, before a couple of crazy women had stolen newborns from hospitals, before the maternity ward was under lock and key. Danielle was more afraid, and when Amber and I went flying in to go look at the babies born that day, we had to convince her to come with us, practically dragging her in with our peer pressure pleas.
We looked up and down the rows of those precious little newborns, and not one of them was named Clearborn, or Clareborn, or Cleary, or Klerbern, or anything else remotely close in spelling or phonetics. We walked out of there so disappointed and dejected. It wasn’t true, there was no baby Clearborn. Then, with an excitement that almost showed the lightbulb over her head, Amber remembered that this isn’t the only place in the Penrose Hospital system where babies were born; there was the main hospital downtown that had a whole floor for their maternity ward. However, we were all meeting at my house again, to try the Ouija board again, and didn’t have time to drive all the way downtown and back. We decided that we would go to Penrose Main the next day after school, to check there. Then, we all hopped into Amber’s car and drove to my house.
We all assembled in the lower part of my parent’s split level house again, and again I got the Ouija board out of the coat closet. Cindy and John again stayed off to the sidelines, notepad in Cindy’s hands, and Brian, Danielle, Amber and I surrounding the Ouija board. Taking a deep breath, we each put our fingertips on the planchette. Immediately, it began going in that fast figure 8, faster and faster. “Uh oh”, I thought, as my heart began to race again.
We asked it “Is this John?” and a quick movement to “No” answered that. We asked “Who are you?” and it refused to answer, just kept moving in a figure 8. We asked it that three times before finally moving on. We then asked “Are you John’s father?”, and the planchette kept moving between “Yes” and “No”, “Yes” and “No”. We asked, “Is John there?”, which was answered with “Yes”. Then, suddenly, it just stopped in the middle for a few seconds, and then spelled out this:
“HEISMINEHEISMINEYOUAREMINEYOUAREALLMINEYOUAREGOINGTODIE
IAMGOINGTOKILLYOUALLKILLYOUALLKILLYOUALLYOUAREMINE
YOUAREMINEYOUAREGOINGTODIE”
And it stopped in the middle again, abruptly, before the fast figure 8’s began again.
This time, Brian’s bravado came out, and he started laughing. He said, “Yeah, right, I know we’re all going to die, everybody’s got to die someday.” The planchette shot to the letters:
“YOUAREFIRSTBRIANYOUAREFIRSTBRIANYOUWILLBEDEADIN
24HOURSYOUAREMINEYOUAREALLMINE”
My eyes grew wider with fear. It had spelled out his name. It had called him out. Brian kept it up though, and laughed, and said “Oh yeah, so I’m going to die in 24 hours. Who else, huh? How you going to do it, tough guy?” The planchette moved quickly to spell out:
“BRIANDIESAMBERDIESJOHNDIESCINDYDIESKRISTINADIESDANIELLEDIES
YOUAREALLMINEYOUWILLALLDIE”
So Brian asked, “Oh yeah? When am I going to die? How am I going to die?”
To which it answered:
“24HOURSBRIANDIES”
Brian’s bravado began to infect us all, and we all let out little laughs at this board that was trying to scare us, or this entity, or whatever. John was pshawing at it all, and said “Danielle’s just doing this to scare us”, to which Danielle cried “I’m not doing it!” We all joined in, though, and began to ask the board when and how we were each going to die, each in turn, each with a sense of sarcasm, challenge and humor.
The board spelled out that Brian and John were going to die in 24 hours, that Amber and Cindy were going to die in 48 hours, and that Danielle and I were going to die in 72 hours. No matter how many times we asked, the board would only move in figure 8’s when we asked HOW we were going to die, or asked for its name.
Brian and John were laughing by now, feeling confident, feeling the spell of obsession broken. I, however, was scared, scared to death. I could see from Amber and Danielle’s face that they were scared, too. Cindy seemed on the fence, a little scared, but feeling John’s confidence, and I think protection. I couldn’t stop thinking “What if it happened, what if it was true?”

We stopped then, some of the spell broken by John and Brian’s laughter over the whole thing. The laughter helped to ease the tension and fear in the room, that moments ago was so thick it was almost choking me. I picked up the board and planchette, noticing that the planchette felt warm this time, where it hadn’t before now, and put them back in their box as everyone was saying goodbye. When everyone had left, the fear came rushing back into me. I wanted to break that board, burn it, throw it out…I never wanted to see it again. I thought about that twice, though, because the wrath of my mother at that time was more fearful than anything some scary ghost demon could promise to do. So, instead, I put it back in the closet.
I knew that I needed to tell my mom what happened, even though I was pretty sure to get in a ton of trouble for having kids in the house without her permission (my mother’s particular pet peeve, and as a normally obedient teenager, this reminds me of how obsessed I had become with our talking with this Ouija board). But, I was so afraid; I felt like I was 5-years-old again, and the boogeyman was in the closet, and I wanted my parents to protect me. I wanted my daddy. Unfortunately, Dad was on the road then as a long-distance truck driver, and so I would have to settle for my mom, which meant I would get in trouble. Dad was definitely the more lenient of the two, and his anger was more understandable. My mother, her anger was so hard to read. But, I also thought that if she knew what had happened, then she would probably get rid of the board. So after dinner, I sat my mom down, and told her the whole story. As I did, I cried and shook, from the sheer terror of it all, and the fear that I and my friends were really going to die in the next 24-72 hours.
My mom was angry, as I had expected, but for reasons that I had not. She was upset because she knew that we had been messing with something dark, something evil, and she was afraid for me, which translated into that unreadable anger. I didn’t find out until years later that her anger stemmed mostly from that, and not that I had disobeyed her wishes about kids in the house. She was mad that that it had gotten a hold of me enough to have me sneaking off to Penrose to go look at babies, that I had become that obsessed with it, and forbade me to go back there, to check again the next day. She tried to forbid me from seeing my friends again, but when I explained that we all had lockers next to each other, and that Brian went to our church, she lightened up and said that we weren’t to ever play with the Ouija board again, and then grounded me for a week for not telling her what I had been doing and having kids in the house without their permission. She took the board out of the closet, and said that she was going to throw it away (I found out years later that she hadn’t, which from what I understand of Ouija boards now, I’m really glad she didn’t. If there is any evil force now attached to that board, it can just stay there for all I care. No need to go breaking or burning it to set that force free to attach to some other vessel.)
I’m not sure why, but getting in trouble over it all seemed to comfort me, make me feel like it was all just a game that I had been playing with my friends, that it was normal. The fear that I was going to die, that my friends were going to die passed into just a mere curiosity. Of course I wanted to see if anything would happen, and so kept in close touch with my friends over the next few days. Cindy did get sick during her supposed time to die, two days later, which had scared me and Danielle when we didn’t see her at her locker that day, but Cindy had called Amber that morning to tell her that she was sick with a cold, so wouldn’t be to school that day. Obviously, I didn’t die either, or I wouldn’t be here to tell you this tale. So, we were all ok.
And I never touched a Ouija board again.

Oh, one thing did happen after all this that spooked me a little. I looked in the Sunday paper after all this had happened, and looked at the Births section. A little 8 lb. 4 oz. boy had been born at Penrose Main Hospital, with the last name of Klerbern.
If you’d like to try a reading with an online Ouija board, as well as learn more of their history and myths, then click here.